I too bought a set of Homemaker's Guild cookware in 1977 and am in need of lid handles. I would love to be able to replace them.
Your problem is the reason I never bought a any cookware with plastic handles. Also never bought a set because in sets there are always some pots/pans one hardly (or never) uses, open stock, when on sale, is the how I bought mine.
I have been also searching for Replacement lids to my pans. I came across this site after reading your post and came back to give it to you. They have a list of replacement lids so I am giving it a try, it does cost money though, hope it can work for us loyal Homemakers guild pan lovers. I have had my set since 1976 and the long handle on the large saucepan snapped in half today..
Contact Regal Ware they replaced my handles for the price of shipping.
firstname.lastname@example.org or call 262-626-2121
© RDA Enthusiast Brands, LLC 2015