100 year old cookie recipe | Taste of Home Community  
Show Subscription Form




100 year old cookie recipe

Last post Jul 07, 2009 2:50 PM by gr_elo . 7 replies.


Forum Jump:
Page 1 of 1 (8 items)
  • 100 year old cookie recipe

    My mom is deceased and I have inherited her box of recipes. One recipe is called CRY BABY COOKIES, noted 100 years old. Ingred. molasses, egg, melted shortening, cloves, cinn. flour, b.soda, and milk.  Some of these recipes are from my grandmother (married 1905), so this could be one of her recipes. Does anyone know where this recipe originated and exactly how old it is.

    Thanks, PLAALT

    False
  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

    WOW, what a real treasure trove you have inherited.

    Does the Cry Baby Cookies give exact measurements? Sounds yummy!

     

    BTW, Welcome to KC!

    False

    "I'll take my freedom, my guns, my money and my religion and you can keep the "CHANGE" - Hank Williams, Jr.

  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

    I have one similar that was called  Darn good cookies and they were like ginger snaps.   Mine is from an older aunt of mine that has been gone many years and I am sure was my grandmothers before my aunt had the recipe.

     

     

    False

  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

    Googled and found .....

     

    Crybaby Cookies

    1 cup      Butter
    1 cup      Sugar
    1 cup      Dark Molasses
    1          Egg, slightly beaten
    1/4 tsp    Salt
    1 tsp.     Vanilla
    2 tsp.     Baking Soda
    1/2 cup    Hot Water
    4 1/2 cups Sifted Flour

          :Mocha Frosting:
    2 Tbsp.    Melted Butter
    4 Tbsp.    Hot Coffee
    2 tsp.     Vanilla
    3 cups     Powdered Sugar

        pre-heat oven to 400 degrees
    Recipe:
    1. Cream butter and sugar until light & fluffy.
    2. Stir in molasses,egg, salt, and vanilla.
    3. Dissolve baking soda in hot water and add alternately with the flour to the butter mixture.

    4. Drop by spoonfuls onto a cookie sheet.
    5. Bake at 400 degrees for 12 minutes (watch closely).

    6. Blend Mocha Frosting ingredients together and spread on HOT cookies.

    False

  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

    There is a similar recipe ina 1848 cookbook I have, but it is not called:  Cry Baby cookie, just : Soft Molasses Cookie.

    My friend who is 89 yrs oldsome times makes the Cry Baby cookies and frosts them with a thin plain vanilla icing.

    Maybe they were called Cry Baby cookies only in certain parts of the country (before people moved around so much)

    False
  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

    I have never put frosting on them but this sounds good.

    False

  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

     Well, except for the milk, those cookie ingredients are pretty close to a recipe I use for peppernuts.  Sounds like a good recipe.  are you willing to share it?

    False
  • Re: 100 year old cookie recipe

    If you Google: Cry Baby Cookies

    you will find find many site with recipes for them.

    False