can you substitute anything for file powder | Taste of Home Community  
Show Subscription Form




can you substitute anything for file powder

Last post Jun 07, 2013 7:01 PM by _FOOTSIE . 10 replies.


Forum Jump:
Page 1 of 1 (11 items)
  • can you substitute anything for file powder

    I would like to try and make  gumbo ( I brought up Emeril's on the web) It sounds so good, but I would never be able to find file powder where I live. I googled it and it says it is sassafras. Can you use something else or omit it altogether

     

    Sheri

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    I would leave it out....but I'd never heard of it until now! LOL

    I did find this...but you probably did too...

    "gumbo file powder is the powdered leaves of the sassafras tree"

    False

    Community Manager

    Taste of Home Magazine

    Feel free to contact me if you have questions or concerns with the Taste of Home website or community.

    PM me here, find me on Facebook or email me sstetzel.toh@gmail.com

    Proudly serving as a Taste of Home Field Editor since 2009.Big Smile

  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    magnabay I don't know where you live but I live in So Calif and they have it in all of  the grocery stores in the isle with all the spices and seasonings and we are as far west as it gets from Louisanan or wherever they  make Gumbo.

    ~Jan~

    False

    SCSG Jan blue eyed mouse siggy

    ~~The most important things in life aren't things!~~ 

      

     


     

  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    I am in Canada at a little beach resort and I know they won't carry this.

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    Sliced pods of okra will thicken your gumbo.  The okra should be young and tender (knife will slide through easily).  Add half a dozen pods and if that doesn't thicken it enough, add a few more pods at a time until it is as thick as you want it.

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    It is a thickener, so cornstarch would be a good alternative as well - just mix it in with water and gently pour it in while stirring. It won't have the "sassafras" flavoring, which if you aren't used to will help if you aren't familiar with it. 

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    I would leave it out. I personally don't care for the flavor so when I make chicken sausage gumbo, I just omit it. Based on where you are, you probably cannot get any okra either.

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    You can get "Gumbo File" at www.penzeys.com. A 1/4 cup jar costs $3.45. 

    False

    AnnStar

  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    I couldn't find it in my area also when I first made gumbo. I used the okra and it came out pretty good.

    Amazon has plenty of file powder-all sizes and prices.

    Enjoy your gumboSmile

    Linda

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    Try using Arrowroot as a thickener.

    False
  • Re: can you substitute anything for file powder

    File powder is added to the individual serving bowls of gumbo just as it's being served, not as a thickener for the whole pot. We've made and eaten more pots of gumbo than I can count and never bothered with the file powder. It truly is not necessary.

    False