American Idol- which David are you pulling for?

I really like both David Cook and David A- think they are both good. looking forward to tonight to see if I can decide which one to vote for. my best friend loves David C- and he can perform. but my sister is pulling for David A- and he has a great voice.  who do you like best and why?

I'm not sure it matters to me which one wins - they are both good.  I'm not sure that David A's music would get as much radio play time as David C.  David A. certainly sings from the heart - with a lot of angst.  But he doesn't strike me as much of an entertainer.  At a concert I think David Cook could entertain me a lot longer than David Archuletta.  IMHO.

 To me they are both winners !!!!! so very different that it really dosen't matter who wins they are both excellent !!!

I also like them both but I am rooting for David C..

Do not like either one, so does not matter one way or the other. But bottom line I guess if I was forced in making a choice it would be David A. David C. is a dirty, scruffy looking guy, looks like he just crawled from under a bridge. Never smiles, looks like it is the last place he wants to be. At least David A. smiles, has a personality  and looks like he is enjoying himself.

IMO both are very talented and I think both will do great, but I prefer David Cook. I really  enjoy both watching David Cook perform and hearing him put his own "spin" on the songs he choses.

 

                            

I agree with most of you- David A has the best voice, vocally- but David C- would be the best performer in concert

trudy1180:

David C. is a dirty, scruffy looking guy, looks like he just crawled from under a bridge. Never smiles, looks like it is the last place he wants to be.

He does too smile, but it is subtle, not the ear to ear one that David A has. As far as the rest of what you said, he did not look that way at first AI tries to make the contestants look like their style of music. Remember how much Clay Aiken changed in season 2. Also remember that he wasn't even there to audition, but the people in charge chose him to at least try out.

I prefer David A over David C. Does anyone know what they will be singing tonight?

David Cook all the way!  David A has absolutely no personality or performance skills.  He has a nice voice but he is like a robot.  David Cook knows how to perform and he is able to take a song and make it his own.  Unfortunately I think that things are swaying in David A's favor which is too bad but I will be voting for David Cook tonight!

trudy1180:

David C. is a dirty, scruffy looking guy, looks like he just crawled from under a bridge.

To each his own, but some of us gals like the rough around the edges look.  Clean cut boys never caught my eye  :)

David Cook has been my favorite performer from the start.

I like David A. the best. I can at least understand the words to the songs when he sings. Most of David C. I cant understand what he is saying.

But hey......I'm a country fan.....so it really doesn't matter to me which one wins.

 I love both David's!!!!!!!!!! Which ever one that wins is fine by me!!

 

Trudy..........LOL You were kidding, weren't you!! LMAO

Cooke for sure.

 

Just wanted to let you all know Luke Menard one of the top 24 has been diagnosed with cancer.

He could use all of our prayers and good thoughts.

He was the acapella handsome singer from Indiana

I'd vote for David C even if he does have that "roadkill" thing under his lip.

David A is creepy.