Seems like the less expensive items go fastest. Our church has a craft fair (I'm always in the kitchen serving lunch) but a scrap booker/paper crafter had huge paper clips topped w/a design - I think she used a large paper punch for various shapes & then embellished them, glued them on top of the paper clips, back to back, so both sides were decorated & charged a dollar for them. Not sure where she got the big paper clips...seems like it would cost me more to make the book marks but they had pumpkins, snowflakes, etc. Holiday-themed pins seemed like a best seller as well as ornaments. Someone had made gift bags for sale....either regular paper sacks or the plain white 'shopping' bags (I've seen them at Michael's & Goodwill shops)...stamped, painted, stenciled, etc. Also, the jars of cookie, quick bread, pancake, muffin, soup mixes with decorated tops seem to be popular too. Good luck!