Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

Last post 07-23-2008 8:55 AM by Abbypuppy. 7 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (8 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-21-2008 5:35 AM

    Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

    I am stuck on the two remaining, I will be happy with either that wins. I did like the room of the brunette that was booted off last night.

    The room the gentleman did last night, the judges seemed split on the 4 leather chairs. I probably would have chose something different but I think it gave a home theater feel to the room as well as a neat and cozy conversation space to hang out.

     

    I liked the blondes viney, free-style leaves she painted on the walls, DD really loved it and wants her to win.

  • 07-21-2008 10:53 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

     Rebecca,

    Bubba and I are Design Star fans. We've watched each season's competition. I have wanted Jennifer from Olathe, KS (the blonde) to win from the beginning. She's from the Midwest and I love her design style.  

    I like Matt too and I think he has really worked on his hosting abilities. I loved the room he designed for his parents. What a tearful reunion! 

    I thought Trish (the brunette) did a great job on her parent's room. She just decorated though. The fireplace was a nice touch. She looked so tired on the show. I'm glad she gets to rest now. Doing a weekly tv show would be so demanding.

    I'm pulling for Jennifer but if Matt wins he'd be great too!   








  • 07-21-2008 11:02 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

    I go with Matt, I guess. I have liked both he and Jennifer from the beginning.

     

    I thought Jennifer was the one who should have gone last night as she really did not do any design, only decorated. She did do her usual artwork on the wall though. Trish redesigned the fireplace, and Matt designed the innovative wall that hid the kiln.

     

    I really like them both, but I think Matt is more creative in his designs, and Jennifer tends to be more of an artist.

  • 07-21-2008 11:43 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

    MountainMan:

    I really like them both, but I think Matt is more creative in his designs, and Jennifer tends to be more of an artist.

     

    I agree.  I have been for Matt since day 1.  I have been looking at the designers in terms of how they might fit into the existing network lineup. Jennifer reminds me of Debbie Travis and her use of paint.  That seems to be her strength and whereas she is very talented, there are already several shows that feature artistic designs.  I am afraid that may be her downfall (just my opinion!) because whereas she is very talented, I am not sure that she has anything unique to offer to the network "as a whole." 

     

    With Matt, he does seem to think more outside the box and I can see that feature being attractive to the network in that it could be marketed as a makeover type show - "Matt's Makeover Magic" (LOL! Don't hate me for the lameness of this - it just came into my mind) Kinda like a "let us help you correct your design flaws" show, which are really popular now. They both have their strengths though - my goodness, look at the competition they had to beat just to make the final two! - I just think his skills/talent seems to be a bit more unique. However, by making the final two, they are both winners if you ask me.

     

    That being said, whereas I have followed it this summer, I have not enjoyed this season of Design Star at all.  I have watched all three years and frankly, I think they have ruined the show this year with their focus on the drama, not the design. I still think Design Star 1 was the best.  I hated all that fuss this season over Michael and Tracee!  And then the deal with Mikey V and his past - geez! I don't watch it for drama, I watch it for ideas and design and I personally think the show has fallen short of that this season.

    "Blessed are those who love cats, for they shall never be lonely. --Unknown"
  • 07-21-2008 12:41 PM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

     I agree about the drama, CatsGalore. I do think there was more of it last season though. It seems they toss in someone with a snotty attitude every year just to throw a wrench into things. 

    I was so surprised when Tracee was gone for 7 hours shopping and then expected the rest of the team to do the backsplash. Time management matters too. 








  • 07-21-2008 1:18 PM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

    i was upset the brunette was voted off..i really like her style..i also think she would make a  good host..i'm rooting for the blonde i liked her room..well her art work on the walls that is..

  • 07-23-2008 3:02 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

    On the whole, I think that the 3rd season is getting better.  Yes, there were some dramatics, tears, and nasty words.  But the group of people seem to be generally more skilled than some they have had in the past. Jennifer and Matt both have limitations, but they will have to shine in the areas that they are best at.  I don't think Matt has a very coordinated, polished style going on.  I guess it  depends on what the network is looking for.  My vote goes to Jennifer because she is very creative, and can technically pull off her design.  Sunday seems a long time to wait. Confused 

  • 07-23-2008 8:55 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone keeping up with HGTV Design Star?

    I thought Trish would win - boy was I wrong.  I'm just glad Tracee isn't on anymore.  It's a toss up between the remaining two, either one is okay.

Page 1 of 1 (8 items)